Upstairs Flooring Showdown: Laminate vs. Vinyl Plank

Selecting the appropriate flooring for upstairs areas is a crucial decision that impacts the aesthetics, comfort, and longevity of your space.

Among the many flooring options available, two contenders often emerge at the forefront of the debate: laminate and vinyl plank flooring.

Each offers unique benefits and drawbacks, which can make the selection process feel quite daunting.

This article examines this complex decision by comparing these two popular options. We will delve into crucial factors such as durability, maintenance, cost-effectiveness, and aesthetic appeal, offering a comprehensive guide to help you make an informed choice for your upstairs flooring.

Laminate Flooring

Before we dive into the intricate details of laminate flooring, let’s understand what it is and what it’s made of.

What is Laminate Flooring Made up of?

Laminate flooring, as I’ve come to learn, is a multi-layer synthetic product fused using a lamination process.

It uses a photographic applique layer under a transparent protective layer to simulate the appearance of natural wood or stone.

I was amazed that the inner core layer typically comprises melamine resin and fiberboard materials.

The Pros of Laminate Flooring

When I first installed laminate flooring in my upstairs bedroom, I was thrilled with its benefits.

1. Durability and Scratch Resistance

One of the reasons I chose laminate flooring was its durability. It’s incredibly resistant to scratches and dents, holding up well against the rigors of daily life. As someone with energetic kids and a hyperactive dog, this was a godsend!

2. Cost-effectiveness

I found laminate flooring to be relatively economical compared to other options.

It’s a fantastic choice if you’re mindful of your budget but still want a great-looking floor.

3. Variety of Styles and Designs

Another aspect I loved about laminate flooring was the vast selection of styles and designs.

There’s a wide variety of colors, patterns, and textures, so you’ll indeed find something that matches your aesthetic.

The Cons of Laminate Flooring

However, like all things, laminate flooring does have its drawbacks.

1. Moisture Susceptibility

One downside I noticed was that laminate flooring isn’t the best regarding moisture resistance. It can warp if exposed to water for prolonged periods, which is something to keep in mind if you have a damp environment.

2. Limited Sound Insulation

Another disadvantage is that laminate flooring doesn’t offer the best sound insulation. This was something I didn’t consider initially, and it became more noticeable when the kids were playing upstairs.

Considerations for Using Laminate Upstairs

Considering laminate flooring for your upstairs, weigh the pros and cons carefully.

Think about your lifestyle, the amount of foot traffic the area will receive, and your budget.

It worked well for my family, but every situation is unique. The best decision is an informed one, so take the time to explore all your options!

Vinyl Plank Flooring

After several years of living with laminate flooring upstairs, I explored other alternatives. That’s when I stumbled upon vinyl plank flooring.

What is Vinyl Plank Flooring Made of?

Vinyl plank flooring, as the name suggests, is a type of flooring that comes in long, narrow strips, similar to wood planks.

It typically comprises several layers, including a vinyl core, a vinyl design layer, and a protective urethane topcoat.

The Pros of Vinyl Plank Flooring

Going with vinyl plank flooring was an exciting experience with plenty of advantages.

1. Waterproof and Moisture-Resistant

Compared to laminate flooring, vinyl planks are completely waterproof, making them an excellent option for damp environments.

This was a game-changer for me, especially in the kids’ bathroom, where spills and splashes occur regularly.

2. Sound Insulation

One of the standout features of vinyl plank flooring for me was its sound insulation properties.

The footsteps of kids running upstairs or the dog scampering about were noticeably less loud, creating a more serene environment.

3. Easy Maintenance and Cleaning

Vinyl plank flooring made my life easier when it came to cleaning.

A quick sweep and occasional mop were all it took to keep the floors looking pristine.

Unlike laminate flooring, I didn’t have to worry about water damage during cleaning.

The Downsides of Vinyl Plank Flooring

However, not everything was rosy with vinyl plank flooring.

1. Susceptibility to Damage from Heavy Furniture

One downside I found was that vinyl plank flooring is susceptible to damage from heavy furniture.

A few months in, I noticed some dents where our heavy bookcase was.

2. Limited Design Options

Another shortcoming was the limited design options.

Unlike laminate flooring, the variety of colors and patterns was somewhat lacking, which meant less room for creativity.

Considerations for Using Vinyl Plank Upstairs

If you’re considering vinyl plank flooring for your upstairs, remember to weigh the pros and cons.

Consider the moisture levels in your home, the amount of noise you can tolerate, your cleaning habits, and of course, your personal style preferences.

I found vinyl plank to be a good fit for my needs, but everyone’s situation is unique. As always, an informed decision is the best decision!

Factors to Consider When Choosing Upstairs Flooring

1. Traffic and Usage Patterns

  • High Traffic Areas vs. Low Traffic Areas

When choosing flooring for your upstairs, it’s crucial to consider the traffic and usage patterns of the area.

For instance, in my house, the kids’ rooms and the hallway are high-traffic areas where there is a constant flurry of activity.

I found that the durability of vinyl plank flooring was a good match for these areas.

In contrast, our home office experiences lower traffic; a more delicate flooring solution might have worked there.

2. Moisture and Humidity Levels

  • Climate Considerations

An important factor that is often overlooked is the moisture and humidity levels in your home.

This is particularly true if you live in a humid climate or have rooms with high moisture, like a bathroom.

In my case, we live in an area with a lot of rainfall, so the water resistance of vinyl plank flooring was a big plus for us.

3. Aesthetics and Style Preferences

Your style also plays a significant role when choosing your flooring.

While vinyl plank flooring was somewhat limited in designs, I found a neutral tone that blended seamlessly with the overall aesthetic of my home.

Remember to pick something that suits your style and compliments your home decor.

4. Budget Considerations

Budget is a significant deciding factor for any home improvement project. With vinyl planks, I found a cost-effective solution that didn’t compromise much on quality.

It’s essential to evaluate your budget and see how it aligns with the cost of materials and installation.

5. Maintenance and Long-term Upkeep

Lastly, consider the long-term upkeep of the flooring.

With two kids and a pet dog, easy maintenance was a high priority for me.

Vinyl plank flooring, with its easy-to-clean nature, proved to be a lifesaver.

However, I did notice the dents caused by heavy furniture over time, so it’s essential to keep such potential issues in mind while making your choice.

Comparing Laminate and Vinyl Plank for Upstairs

1. Durability and Resistance to Wear and Tear

Having experimented with laminate and vinyl plank flooring in different parts of my home, I’ve had the chance to evaluate their durability side by side.

While both held up reasonably well, the vinyl plank flooring showed more resistance to scrapes and dents, especially in high-traffic areas like the hallway.

On the flip side, my laminate flooring has withstood the test of time in the bedrooms, even with the kids and dog often creating havoc!

2. Resistance to Moisture and Humidity

I live in a high-rainfall area, and moisture resistance is a critical factor for me. Here, vinyl plank flooring won hands down.

It’s proven an excellent choice for bathrooms and the kitchen, withstanding spills and moisture without significant damage.

Laminate, while not a bad performer, did show signs of wear over time in these high-moisture areas.

3. Sound Insulation and Noise Reduction

Being a parent, I deeply value a quiet and peaceful home.

With laminate flooring, the upstairs bedrooms became noticeably quieter.

It surprisingly provided better sound insulation than its vinyl counterpart.

Fewer noise disruptions during the kids’ nap times? That was a win for me!

4. Aesthetics and Design Options

In terms of aesthetics, both options have their charm.

Laminate flooring has a variety of design options, which allowed me to play around with different looks for each room.

Vinyl plank flooring, although more limited in variety, offered a sleek, modern look that I found visually pleasing.

5. Cost-Effectiveness and Budget-Friendliness

Budget is always a significant factor in home improvement projects.

Vinyl plank flooring was a cost-effective solution for me, offering durability without breaking the bank.

Laminate, while a bit pricier, added a touch of elegance to the rooms.

Both were budget-friendly in their ways, depending on what I prioritized more — durability or aesthetics.

6. Ease of Installation and Maintenance

Ease of installation and maintenance is another crucial factor I considered.

Both vinyl plank and laminate flooring were relatively simple to install, but vinyl planks took the lead with their straightforward, peel-and-stick installation method.

Regarding maintenance, vinyl again won with its easy-to-clean nature, a massive plus for a busy mom like me.

Making the Decision

When it came time for the final decision, I needed to step back and evaluate my specific needs and preferences.

Assessing your specific needs and preferences

Each home, and each room within it, has its own unique needs.

For the kids’ play area, I was looking for something durable to withstand the tornado of toys.

For the master bedroom, on the other hand, I wanted something elegant and quiet – a haven where I could retreat from the chaos.

Weighing the pros and cons of laminate and vinyl plank

I spent much time comparing the pros and cons of laminate and vinyl plank flooring.

I loved the variety and elegance of laminate, but the durability and ease of maintenance that vinyl offered were equally appealing.

I made sure to evaluate each room individually and consider which features were the most important for that space.

Considering budget and long-term maintenance

Budgeting was a massive part of my decision. I had to think about not just the upfront costs of the flooring but also the long-term maintenance.

With two young kids in the house, I knew that whatever I chose would need to withstand a lot of spills and messes.

Ultimately, I found that while laminate might be a bit pricier upfront, its durability might mean fewer replacements in the long run.

Seeking professional advice if needed

Lastly, I sought professional advice. Even though I did a lot of research independently, speaking to a flooring specialist gave me additional insight into the quality of the materials and installation tips.

This expert advice helped me feel more confident about my purchases and made the installation process smoother.

In the end, I chose a mix of both vinyl and laminate flooring — vinyl for the kids’ playrooms and laminate for the bedrooms and living room.

This decision allowed me to balance my budget, meet the specific needs of each room, and achieve the aesthetics I wanted.


Hi! I’m Kobby, one of the co-owners of and the newest house owner in town. I’m a huge fan of most things natural. Over here on this site, I'm happy to share all the exciting hacks, tricks, and tips I have learned and continue to learn each day about taking care of natural stones.

Recent Posts